Restrictive Food Rules and the Need for Control

Spotify Apple Podcasts Castbox PocketCasts YouTube

Holistic nutrition gave Lisa Chilvers a different way to see food. After years of poor body image, binge eating disorder, and disordered eating, she began to understand how food and nutrients could support her digestion, eczema, and capacity to handle stressors.

But that discovery did not immediately end her need for control. Restrictive rules could still turn eating into a test, with self-blame waiting whenever her body did not respond as expected.

That tension matters to me. What happens when we do all the "right" things and still feel unwell, anxious, or at the end of our rope?

What happens when we do all the "right" things and still feel unwell, anxious, or at the end of our rope?

When healthy eating becomes another form of control

Lisa's experiences with eczema and irritable bowel syndrome shaped an approach that combines nutrition, bioenergetics, and mind-body practices. Yet learning more about nutrition did not automatically bring ease. Knowledge can help, but it can also give the internal mean coach more material to use against us.

Lisa now often works with women who already understand healthy eating. They have tried diets, followed prescribed protocols, lost and gained weight, and worked hard to comply. Still, something feels unresolved. When an IBS reaction appears, the questions come quickly: What did I eat? What did I do wrong? A physical symptom becomes evidence, and the person eating is once again held responsible.

Her work is not primarily about weight loss. It addresses how people think about and approach food, emotions, and behavior, including anxiety, emotional eating, nighttime eating, and binge eating disorder. Another plan may change what is on the plate without addressing the fear, urgency, or self-criticism around it.

Why Lisa questions restrictive food rules

A generalized elimination protocol may remove many foods before slowly adding them back over perhaps six months. For someone already vulnerable to disordered eating or food relationship issues, that process can reinforce excessive control. The search for clarity may leave fewer foods that feel acceptable, while every symptom starts to look like proof of failure.

The search for clarity may leave fewer foods that feel acceptable, while every symptom starts to look like proof of failure.

Lisa uses biofield testing and muscle testing, also called applied kinesiology, to identify patterns she describes as weakening or strengthening. She is equally clear about the limits: biofield testing is reflective, not diagnostic. Expectations about a food can influence the result. Hydration, crossed legs, attention, and emotional state are among the variables she tries to manage.

She considers those patterns alongside symptoms and quantifiable information. If iron and B12 appear alongside fatigue, , intense periods, and blood loss, she may recommend medical blood work. That boundary matters. Lisa's own experiences led her to incorporate bioenergetics and frequency-based work, but she does not present the information as a diagnosis or a reason to abandon appropriate medical testing.

Replacing the mean coach with awareness and regulation

The Loving Kindness Method is a six-month program, and Lisa prefers at least three sessions for integrative health work involving bioenergetics. That time frame leaves little room for the fantasy of a one-off answer. Depending on the person, she may use coaching, tapping, thought field therapy, emotional freedom technique, bioenergetics, and rather than impose the same protocol on everyone.

Sometimes the work is as immediate as learning to feel a difficult emotion or remain present with the urge to eat at night. Instead of answering discomfort with another rigid plan, a person can notice what is happening in the body and mind. That awareness allows time to respond before the impulse to control food takes over.

Instead of answering discomfort with another rigid plan, a person can notice what is happening in the body and mind.

I keep returning to how easily we become "mean about the meanness." We notice that we are being self-critical, then criticize ourselves for that too. But noticing is not another failure. It is a chance to catch the familiar pattern, pause, and respond with compassion before adding another rule. We do not have to criticize ourselves into becoming healthier.

Other things you might like

Episode 73: If Abundance Is Our Birthright, Why Isn't Feeling Good in Our Bodies? Nov 13, 2026
Episode 71: You're Doing All the Right Exercises. So Why Are You Still in Pain? Nov 5, 2026
Episode 70: You're Allowed to Change Your Mind (And Your Life) with Kim Brooks Nov 2, 2026
Episode 69: Are You Avoiding Exercise to Avoid Injury? Oct 28, 2026
Episode 68: What If Slowing Down Doesn't Mean Sitting Still? with Alana Winchester Oct 19, 2026
Episode 67: Why Is My Physiotherapist Telling Me to Slow Down? Oct 15, 2026